Magic: The Gathering (MTG), a game with a rich history and a vast array of mechanics, constantly evolves to keep the gameplay fresh and engaging. One tool used by the game’s designers to evaluate the likelihood of a mechanic’s return is the Storm Scale. Named after the “Storm” mechanic, the Storm Scale helps gauge how likely it is for a particular mechanic to reappear in future sets. This article delves into what the Storm Scale is, how it works, and what it means for MTG players.
What is the Storm Scale?
The Storm Scale is a rating system devised by Mark Rosewater, MTG’s head designer, to measure the likelihood of a particular mechanic being reused in future sets. The scale ranges from 1 to 10, with 1 indicating a high likelihood of return and 10 suggesting a very low chance of reappearance. The name “Storm Scale” comes from the “Storm” mechanic, which has a high complexity and power level, making it an unlikely candidate for frequent reprints.
How Does the Storm Scale Work?
The Storm Scale takes into account several factors when evaluating a mechanic:
- Complexity: Mechanics that are easy to understand and implement are more likely to return. Complex mechanics, which may confuse new players or require intricate rules interactions, tend to have a higher Storm Scale rating.
- Power Level: Overly powerful mechanics can warp the game environment, leading to unbalanced gameplay. Such mechanics are given higher Storm Scale ratings to prevent them from dominating the game.
- Popularity: Some mechanics are fan favorites and are requested often by players. These mechanics are more likely to see a return, resulting in a lower Storm Scale rating.
- Design Space: This refers to the potential for creating new cards and interactions with the mechanic. If a mechanic has a lot of unexplored design space, it is more likely to come back.
- Set Fit: Certain mechanics fit well within specific set themes or blocks. Mechanics that are versatile and can be adapted to various themes are more likely to return.
Examples of Mechanics on the Storm Scale
Here are some examples of mechanics and their positions on the Storm Scale:
- 1-3 (Highly Likely to Return):
- Scry: This mechanic allows players to look at the top card(s) of their library and decide whether to keep them there or put them on the bottom. It’s simple, popular, and versatile.
- Flying: A fundamental keyword ability that provides evasion. It’s a staple of the game and appears in almost every set.
- 4-6 (Moderately Likely to Return):
- Flashback: This mechanic lets players cast spells from their graveyard, offering extra value. It has moderate complexity but is well-loved by players.
- Kicker: Allows players to pay an additional cost to get a bonus effect. It’s flexible and offers interesting decision points but requires more complexity in card design.
- 7-9 (Unlikely to Return):
- Storm: This mechanic allows players to copy a spell for each spell cast before it during the turn. It’s powerful and complex, often leading to game-breaking combos.
- Phasing: A complex mechanic that can lead to confusion, making it less likely to reappear.
- 10 (Extremely Unlikely to Return):
- Banding: An old and highly complex mechanic that confuses even experienced players. It is unlikely to return due to its complexity and lack of popularity.
Impact of the Storm Scale on Players
For players, the Storm Scale provides insight into the design philosophy of MTG and helps set expectations for future sets. Mechanics with lower ratings might be more common in upcoming expansions, allowing players to plan their deck-building strategies accordingly. Conversely, mechanics with higher ratings might become cherished memories, with occasional nostalgic reprints in special sets.
Conclusion
The Storm Scale is a valuable tool for MTG designers and players alike. It offers a glimpse into the decision-making process behind the game’s evolving mechanics and helps manage expectations for the future. While not every beloved mechanic will make a triumphant return, understanding the factors that influence these decisions can enhance our appreciation for the game’s rich design and history. Whether you’re a seasoned player or new to the game, the Storm Scale is a fascinating aspect of MTG’s ever-evolving landscape.
